登录 | 注册 | 充值 | 退出 | 公司首页 | 繁体中文 | 满意度调查
综合馆
论优选论的功能主义倾向
  • 摘要

    优选论的近期研究呈现功能主义倾向,其主要表现就是把标记类制约条件和忠实类制约条件建立在语音的生理、物理、感知和功能原则基础之上.对于形式理论来说,制约条件的功能化带来一系列严重的理论后果:音系语法不再是语言知识而是行为知识;音系失去语法本体地位;制约条件源于开放的物质世界,因此在数量上是无限的;制约条件具有经验基础,因此不必是先天的.导致这些理论后果的根本原因是优选论缺少符合形式理论要求的语法构建原则.

  • 作者

    李兵 

  • 作者单位

    南开大学

  • 刊期

    2008年1期 PKU CSSCI

  • 关键词

    优选论功能主义  生理  物理  感知行为 

参考文献
  • [1] 李兵. 优选论中的音系晦暗性:问题与发展. 外语教学与研究, 2005,3
  • [2] Reiss,C. Language change without constraint reranking. Dordrecht:Khwer, 2003
  • [3] Sagey,E.C. The representation of features and relations in non-hnear phonology. MIT,Cambridge,MA, 1986
  • [4] 本文所引用的英文原文均由笔者译成中文.
  • [5] 例如 Chomsky和Lsnik(1977)认为,虽然具有普遍意义的功能性限制没有语法地位和语法作用,但是此类限制有可能在人类进化层次上具有一定的意义.
  • [6] Smith,N;J.McGilveray. Chomsky's science of language. 2005
  • [7] Steriade,D. A Note on Coronal. Cambridge,ma:the Mit Press, 1986
  • [8] Tesar,B;P.Smolensky. Leamability in Optimality Theory. Cambridge,ma:the Mit Press, 2000
  • [9] Trubetzkoy,N.S;C.A.M.Bahaxe. Gmndz ge der Phonologie.Travaux du Cerele Linguistique de Prague,7,Prague. Berkeley:University of California Press, 1939
  • [10] Wilso,C. Consonant clusters neutralization and targeted constraints. Phonology, 2001
  • [11] Anderson,S.R. The Organization of Phonology. New York:Seminar Press, 1974
  • [12] Anderson,S.R. Why phonology isn't"natural". Linguistic Inquiry, 1981
  • [13] Anttila,A;Y.Y.Cho. Variation and change in Optimality Theory. Oxford:Blackwefll, 2004
  • [14] Archangeli,D. Aspecm of underspecification theory. Phonology, 1988
  • [15] Archangeli,D. OptimMity Theory:An introduction to linguistics. Oxford:Blackwell Scientific Publications, 1997
  • [16] Beckman,J. Positional Faithfulness. University of Massachusetts,Amherst, 1998
  • [17] Blevins,J. Evolutionary Phonology:The Emergence of Sound Patterns. Cambridge:Cambridge University Press, 2004
  • [18] Boemma,P. Functional Phonology:Formalizing the Interaction between Articulatory and Perceptual Drives. The Hague:Holland Academic Graphics, 1998
  • [19] Boemma,P. Learning a grammar in functional phonology. Oxford:Oxford University Press, 2000
  • [20] 优选论倡导者对形式特点的理解并不完全相同.Prince and Smolensky(1993:67)认为,"优选论由两个部分组成:一个是关于音系合格形式的内容共性理论,另一个是关于制约条件交互作用的形式共性理论."这就是说,制约条件本身不必是音系语法知识.据此,音系语法仅仅是一种把以经验为基础的语音一功能知识,即制约条件,组织起来的方式.
  • [21] Boemma,P. The odds of external optimization in OptimMity Theory. Dordrecht:Kluwer Publishing, 2003
  • [22] Bromberger,S. On What We Know We Don't Know:Explanation,Theory,Linguistws,and How Questions Shape Them.CSLI Publications. Chicago.IL:University of Chicago Press, 1992
  • [23] Bromberger,S;M.Halle. Why phonology is different. Linguistic Inquiry, 1989
  • [24] Chomsky,N. Some general properties of phonological rules. Language, 1967
  • [25] Chomsky,N. Problems of Knowledge and Freedom. New York:Random House, 1971
  • [26] Chomsky,N. Language and Mind. New York:Harcourt Brace Jovanovich,Inc, 1972
  • [27] Chomsky,N. Rules and Representations. Oxford:Blackwell Scientific Publications, 1980
  • [28] 除此之外,"位置忠实"(poeidonal faithulnees,Beckman,1998)和"有目标的制约条件"(targeted constraint,Wil-son,2001)也具有明显的功能主义倾向.由于篇幅有限,本文不讨论这两个概念.
  • [29] Chomsky,N. Lectures ott Goverrtment and Bindling. Dordreeht:Foris, 1981
  • [30] Chomsky,N. Markedness and core grammar. Pisa:Souola Normale Superiore di Pisa, 1981
  • [31] Bromberger,S. The ontology of phonology(revised). Oxford:Oxford University Press, 2000
  • [32] Chomsky,N. Review of Skinner(1957). Language, 1959,01
  • [33] Chomsky,N. Aspects of the Theory of Syntax. Cambridge,ma:the Mit Press, 1965
  • [34] Chomsky,N. The Generative Enterprise. Dordrecht:Foris, 1982
  • [35] Chomsky,N. The Generative Enterprise Revisited. Berlin:Mouton de Gruyter, 2004
  • [36] Chomsky,N;H.Lasnik. Filters and control. Linguistic Inquiry, 1977
  • [37] Chomsky,N. Knowledge of Language. New York:Preager Press, 1986
  • [38] Chomsky,N. The Minimalist Program. Cambridge,ma:the Mit Press, 1995
  • [39] Chomsky,N. Some observations on economy in Generative Grammar. Cambridge,ma:the Mit Press, 1998
  • [40] Chomsky.N;M.Halle. The Sound Pattern of English. New York:Harper and Row Publishers, 1968
  • [41] Comrie,B. Language Universals and Language Typology. Oxford:Blackwell Scientific Publications, 1981
  • [42] Craln,S. Nature,nurture and Universal Grammar. Linguistics and Philosophy, 2001
  • [43] Croft,W. Typology and UniversMs. Cambridge:Cambridge University Press, 1990
  • [44] Donegan,P;D.Stampe. The study of natural phonology. Bloomington:Indiana University Press, 1979
  • [45] Dresher,E.B. Analogical leveling of vowel length in West Germanic. Berlin:Mouton de Gruyter, 2000
  • [46] Dresher,E.B;J.McGilveray. Chomsky and Halle's revolution in phonology. 2005
  • [47] Flemming,E. Scalar and categorical phenomena in a unified model of phonetics and phonology. Phonology, 2001,01
  • [48] Flemming,E. Contrast and perceptual distinctiveness. Cambridge:Cambridge University Press, 2004
  • [49] Goldsmith,J.A. Autosegmemal Phonology. Bloomington:Indiana University Linguistics Club, 1976
  • [50] Flemming(2004)四等分元音高度维向上的感知空间.
  • [51] Goldsmith,J.A. Autosegmemal and Metrical Phonology. Oxford:Blackwell Scientific Publications, 1990
  • [52] Greenberg,J.H. Universals of Human Language Vol,2:Phonology. Stanford,California:Stanford University Press, 1978
  • [53] Clements,G.N. The geometry of phonological features. Phonology Yearbook, 1985
  • [54] Kirchner(2004)提出了"理想环境中的典型样本"概念,试图排除不直接相关的言语行为因素的影响.但这个概念仍然属于语言运用范畴,不能说明物理事件和语法知识的关系.
  • [55] Clements,G.N;K.Ford. Kikuyu tone shift and its synchronic consequences. Linguistic Inquiry, 1979
  • [56] Halle,M. Formal versus Functional Considerations in Phonology. Bloomington:Indiana University Linguistics Club, 1978
  • [57] Halle,M;J.-R.Vergnaud. Three dimensional phonology. Journal of Linguistic Research, 1980
  • [58] Halle,M;K.Stevens. Knowledge of language and the sounds of speech. London:Macmillan, 1991
  • [59] Hayes,B. Metrical Stress Theory:Principles and Case Studies. Chicago,IL:Chicago University Press, 1995
  • [60] Hayes,B. Phonetically driven phonology:The role of Optimality Theory and inductive grounding. Amsterdam:John Benjamins, 1999
  • [61] Kiparsky(1968)认为,如果语音演变是音系规则应用顺序发生变化的结果,那么,最大限度地应用音系规则是规则顺序发生变化的目的.因此,音系规则之间的关系趋于向馈给顺序和反阻断顺序演变.据此,语法优化的本质是数量上最少的音系规则能够推导出所有可能的表层形式.
  • [62] Hayes,B. Phonological acquisition in Optimality Theory:The early stages. Cambridge:Cambridge University Press, 2004
  • [63] Hayes,B;D.Steriade. Introduction:The phonetic bases of phonological markedness. Cambridge:Cambridge University Press, 2004
  • [64] Hulst,H.van der. Atoms of segmental structure:components,gestures,and dependency. Phonology, 1989
  • [65] Hulst,H van der;N.Smith. The Structure of Phonological Representation Pan I and Part Dordrecht:Foris. 1982
  • [66] Jakobson,R. Typological studies and their contribution to historical comparative linguistics. Oslo:Oslo University Press, 1958
  • [67] Jakobson,R. Kindersprache.aphasic und allgemeine Lantgesetze. The Hague:Mouton Publishers, 1941
  • [68] Halle,M. Feature geometry and feature spreading. Linguistic Inquiry, 1995
  • [69] Halle,M. From Memory to Speech and Back. Berhn:Mouton de Gruyter, 2002
  • [70] Hale,M;C.Reiss. Phonology as cognition. Oxford:Oxford University Press, 2000
  • [71] Kager,R. optimality Theory. Cambridge:Cambridge University Press, 1999
  • [72] Kaye,J;J.Lowenstamm;J.-R.Vergnaud. The internal structure of phonological elements:A theory of charm and government. Phonology Yearbook, 1985
  • [73] Keating,P.A. Phonetic representations in a generative grammar. Journal of Phonetics, 1990
  • [74] Kenstowicz,M;C.Kisseberth. Topics in Phonologcal Theory. New York:Academic Press,Inc, 1977
  • [75] 这里涉及儿童语言习得在语言演变过程中的作用问题(Lightfoot,1993;Crain,2001;Reiss,2003).
  • [76] Kiparsky,P. Linguistic universals and linguistic change. New York:Holt, 1968
  • [77] Kiparsky,P. Lexical phonology and morphology. Seoul:Hanshin, 1982
  • [78] Kiparsky,P. Analogy as optimization:"Exceptions"to Sievers'Law in Gothic. Berlin:Mouton de Gruyter, 2000
  • [79] Kirchner,R. Consonant lenition. Cambridge:Cambridge University Press, 2004
  • [80] Lakoff,G. Women,Fire,and Dangerous Things:What Categories Reveal about the Mind. Chicago:the University of Chicago Press, 1987
  • [81] Leben,W. Suprasegmental phonology. Cambridge,MA:The MIT, 1973
  • [82] Lighffeot,D. Why UG needs a learning theory:Triggering verb movement. London:Longman, 1993
  • [83] Lighffeot,D;J.McGilveray. Plato's problem,UG,and the language organ. 2005
  • [84] Lindblom,B. Explaining phonetic variation:A sketch of the H and H theory. Dordrecht:Kluwer Publishing, 1990
  • [85] McCarthy,J. Formal problems in Semic phonology and morphology. Cambridge,MA:The MIT, 1979
  • [86] 这里不考虑词汇习得以及词汇习得与音系习得的关系.
  • [87] McCarthy,J. OCP Effects:Gemination and Antigemination. Linguistic Inquiry, 1986
  • [88] McCarthy,J. A Thematic Guide to optiality Theory. Cambridge:Cambridge University Press, 2002
  • [89] McCarthy,J. OT constraints are categorical. Phonology, 2003,01
  • [90] McCarthy,J;A.Prince. Prosodic morphology I:Constraint interaction and satisfaction. University of Maszachusetts,Amherst/Rutgers University,New Brunswick, 1993
  • [91] McCarthy,J. The emergence of the unmarked. Oxford:Blackwell Scientific Publications, 2004
  • [92] Miglio,V. Markedness and Faithfulness in Vowel Systems. London:Routledge, 2005
  • [93] Minkova.D;R.Stockwell. English vowel shifts and"optimal"diphthongs:Is there a logical link?. Dordrecht:Kluwer Publishing, 2003
  • [94] Hayes(2004)认为,虽然制约条件具有语音基础,但制约条件本身不是语音模式,因此应当允许制约条件偏离语音模式.
  • [95] Mohanan,K.P. Lexical phonology. Bloomington:Indiana University Linguistics Club, 1982
  • [96] Newmeyer,F. Language Form and Language Function. Cambridge,ma:the Mit Press, 1998
  • [97] Odden,D. On the role of the obligatory contour principle in phonological theory. Language, 1986
  • [98] Odden,D. Antigemination and the OCP. Linguistic Inquiry, 1988
  • [99] Petitto,L.-A;J.McGilveray. How the brain beset.language. 2005
  • [100] Pierrehumbert,J.B. The Phonetics and Phonology of English Intonation. New York:Garland, 1980
  • [101] Pietrosky,P;S.Crain;J.McGilveray. Innate ideas. 2005
  • [102] Prince.A;P.Smolensky. Optimality Theory:Constraint interaction in Generative Grammar. Rutgers University,New Brunswick/University of Colorado,Boulder, 1993
  • [103] Pulleyblank,D. Tone in Lexical Phnobgy. Dordrecht:Reidel, 1986
  • [104] Raffelsiefen,R. Constraints on schwa apocope in Middle High German. Bedin:Mouton de Gruyter, 2000
  • [105] McCawley,J.D. On the role of nomtion in generative phonology. Oxford:Blackwell Scientific Publications, 1999
  • [106] McGilveray,J. The Cambridge Companion to Chomsky. Cambridge:Cambridge University Press
  • [107] Miglio,V. The Great Vowel Shift:An OT model for unconditional language change. University of Muenster,German, 1998
查看更多︾
相似文献 查看更多>>
3.80.128.196